Comparison · Commercial decorators

A Star Decorators vs Bagnalls.

Both deliver commercial decorating on UK frameworks. Bagnalls win on heritage and 17-branch national coverage. A Star wins on director-led operational discipline at the individual-job level. Here is the honest pick.

Request a site survey Call 077 6178 1304

Working with

Uplands RetailR.G. CarterMorris & Spottiswood

In environments

PrimarkTescoM&SMorrisons

01 / Bagnalls on the public record

What Bagnalls say about themselves.

These are the facts Bagnalls publish on their own site and verifiable third-party sources. The comparison below uses only these claims for Bagnalls, and verifiable A Star claims for us.

Founded 1875. 17 branches across the UK. ~700 directly-employed staff including ~600 painters and decorators.
Source: bagnalls.co.uk
Direct-employment model. Worker retention with many staff over 25 years.
Source: Indeed company reviews
Sector range from royal palaces to factories, offices, hospitals and schools.
Source: bagnalls.co.uk

02 / lever-by-lever

Where the two firms differ.

Heritage and scale

Bagnalls

150 years, 17 UK branches, ~700 staff.

A Star

Founded 2003. South-coast base. UK-wide on framework programmes.

Site-level accountability

Bagnalls

Branch-manager model — the operative on site is one layer down from the commercial decision.

A Star

Director-led. The director who signs the AfP is the one who walked the site. No middle layer.

RAMS and handover discipline

Bagnalls

Standard tier-1 contractor approach.

A Star

RAMS 48 hours before mobilisation. Per-zone photo handover. Snag list closed within a working week.

Health and safety

Bagnalls

Full ISO stack and SSIP.

A Star

In-house NEBOSH and SMSTS (Karol Rutkowski, H&S Advisor). CHAS accredited. £10m Employer's Liability. RAMS and COSHH led in-house, not subbed.

Specialist niches

Bagnalls

Heritage and decorative are strengths. Industrial and intumescent are within range but not headline.

A Star

Live-trading capable. Intumescent on structural steel, DOFF cleaning, powder-coat and aluminium frame restoration, on-site spraying — all delivered around occupied operations.

Geography

Bagnalls

National via 17 branches.

A Star

South of England based. UK-wide through main-contractor frameworks (Uplands Retail, R.G. Carter, Morris & Spottiswood).

03 / the honest pick

Which firm fits which problem.

Pick Bagnalls if

Procurement comfort weighs heaviest and a 150-year heritage matters to the framework decision.
You need a local branch presence in a region A Star does not currently work.
Your spec is heritage decorative finishes on a listed national monument.

Pick A Star if

Your programme depends on the decorator absorbing live-trading moves without slipping.
You want the director who signs the AfP to be the one who walked the site.
Your scheme runs on retail rollout frameworks (Tesco, M&S, Primark) and you want the same team across the rolling weekends.
You need a specialist niche done right: intumescent, DOFF, powder-coat restoration, on-site spraying.
You are tired of decorators that need chasing for variations, AfPs and snag close-out.

Both firms are legitimate UK commercial decorators. Bagnalls' value is scale and heritage. A Star's value is operational discipline at the individual-scheme level and direct accountability to the director. Pick the one that matches the problem you are trying to solve.

Start a conversation

Send photos, drawings or a short scope.

We will review the service route, access, preparation, finish and likely next step before the job is priced properly.

Talk to the project lead Call now